4* Alexander's Guesthouse
Alexander's Guesthouse, Fleming Street, Key West, FL, USA
GayMapper Favourite, Gay Hotel
Alexander's Guesthouse has been welcoming LGBTQ+ travellers to Key West for years, and the friendly, personal atmosphere is still the reason we like it so much. The gay-owned guesthouse occupies a cluster of beautifully restored Conch houses on a quiet Old Town street, around ten minutes on foot from Duval.
Breakfast and the daily complimentary happy hour naturally bring guests together, while the pool, hot tub and sun decks give you plenty of space to relax without the feel of a large resort. Solo travellers tend to find it especially easy to meet people here.
You’re close enough to walk to the nightlife but far enough away that Fleming Street stays pleasantly residential.
GayMapper tip: our favourite if you want a genuinely LGBTQ-centred stay that feels friendly and sociable without becoming a party resort.
Hotels you might like in Key West
4* The Saint Hotel Key West
Near Gay Nightlife, Luxury
3* La Te Da
Near Gay Nightlife, Adults Only
2* New Orleans House
Gay Hotel, Near Gay Nightlife
4* Simonton Court Inn
Near Gay Nightlife, Adults Only
3* The Paradise Inn
Near Gay Nightlife, Adults Only
3* NYAH Key West
Adults Only, Great Value
See something wrong?
Send us a message!















